Resolução estética de lesões de mancha branca pós-tratamento ortodôntico
Carregando...
Data
2021-07-07
Autores
Rocha, Rafael Santos
Título da Revista
ISSN da Revista
Título de Volume
Editor
Universidade Estadual Paulista (Unesp)
Resumo
O objetivo deste estudo foi comparar as técnicas de microabrasão de esmalte (ME) e infiltração de resina (IR) em relação à resolução estética de lesões cariosas de mancha branca (LCMB) e avaliar a correlação entre a luminosidade das lesões quando transiluminadas e a resolução do problema (estudo 1); avaliar em um estudo “in vitro”, a eficácia do clareamento dental, em amostras de dentes submetidos previamente a IR (estudo 2); avaliar a efetividade do clareamento dental 12 meses após a realização dos protocolos de mínima intervenção, em um estudo de série de casos (estudo 3). Para o estudo 1 foram selecionados 17 pacientes que foram divididos em 2 grupos: ME (N=8) e IR (N=9). Um dente de cada paciente foi fotografado sob condição normal e do mesmo dente com auxilio de dispositivo translume. Em seguida os pacientes foram submetidos às técnicas de mínima intervenção. Após 7 dias de acompanhamento, o mesmo protocolo fotográfico foi realizado. Para resolução estética, foi delimitado a área do dente em relação a área da mancha por software. Para avaliação da cor da mancha quando evidenciada, os valores de luminosidade (L*) das coordenadas L*a*b* foram avaliados antes e após a intervenção, sendo mensurados valores das áreas sadias e área da mancha mais enegrecida. Os dados de correlação foram submetidos ao teste de Person. A resolutividade dos tratamentos foi dada por um Teste t-Student e a diferença de luminosidade antes e após os tratamentos foi dado pelo teste Anova 2 fatores de medidas repetidas (p<0,05). Para o estudo 2, quarenta superfícies de esmalte bovino foram submetidas à desmineralização. Após, foram estabelecidos dois protocolos de manchamento. Vinte espécimes foram imersos em caldo de manchamento por 24 horas (Lab 1) ou 7 dias (Lab 2). Dez corpos-de-prova de cada grupo receberam a aplicação de IR. Todas as amostras foram clareadas com gel de peróxido de carbamida 15% por 14 dias (8 horas diárias). A mensuração da cor foi realizada em espectrofotômetro de refletância em três momentos: inicial, após o manchamento e após o clareamento. Os dados (CIEDE00) foram analisados pelo teste t-Student (p <0,05). Para o estudo 3, foram selecionados 4 voluntários, que tinham LCMB nos dentes anteriores superiores. Os pacientes foram divididos de forma aleatória em dois grupos, sendo estes: ME e IR na área de mancha. Para resolução estética das LCMB, foi determinada a área da mancha em relação a área do dente e a porcentagem da redução pós protocolos. Após 12 meses de acompanhamento, os pacientes receberam clareamento dental, com peróxido de carbamida 10%, durante 21 dias. Os dados do estudo 1 mostram que não houve correlação entre as áreas da mancha (normal e transiluminada) e a resolução estética das mesmas (p>0.05). Em relação a resolutividade, não houve diferença entre os tratamentos (p=0.403). O valor de Luminosidade aumentou após a realização dos procedimentos (p=0.001). Para o estudo 2, nenhuma diferença significativa foi observada no Lab 1 (p=0,560). Para o Lab 2, foram detectadas diferenças significativas (p=0,031). Uma vez que o clareamento foi mais efetivo no grupo não submetido a IR (Lab2). Os resultados do estudo 3 mostram que ambos os protocolos reduziram e/ou suavizaram as áreas das manchas. Após 12 meses de acompanhamento, a técnica de ME apresentou redução no valor da área de mancha. Por fim, o clareamento dental foi efetivo em ambos os protocolos, sem diferenças entre as técnicas. Frente as metodologias propostas, pode-se concluir que: não houve diferenças entre os tratamentos em relação a remoção ou mascaramento das LCMB; a cor das manchas quando transiluminadas não estão relacionadas a resolução estética das mesmas; “in vitro”, dentes fortemente manchados, submetidos ao tratamento com RI, o produto parece se comportar como uma barreira semipermeável à penetração do peróxido. Por fim, ambas as técnicas podem ser indicadas para reduzir ou suavizar as áreas de mancha. A ME apresentou redução das áreas de mancha no período avaliado (12 meses). Clinicamente, o clareamento dental pode ser indicado para melhorar a cor dos dentes, independentemente do protocolo pré-estabelecido.
The aim of this study was to compare enamel microabrasion (EM) and resin infiltration (RI) techniques in relation to the esthetic resolution of white spot carious lesions (WSL) and to evaluate the correlation between the luminosity of the lesions when transilluminated and the resolution of the problem (study 1); To evaluate in an "in vitro" study, the effectiveness of dental bleaching in samples of teeth previously submitted to RI (study 2); to evaluate the effectiveness of dental bleaching 12 months after the minimal intervention protocols were performed, in a case series study (study 3). For study 1, 17 patients were selected and divided into 2 groups: ME (N=8) and IR (N=9). One tooth from each patient was photographed under normal condition and the same tooth with the aid of a translume device. Then the patients were subjected to the minimal intervention techniques. After 7 days of follow-up, the same photographic protocol was performed. For esthetic resolution, the area of the tooth was delimited in relation to the area of the stain using software. To evaluate the color of the stain when evidenced, the luminosity values (L*) of the coordinates L*a*b* were evaluated before and after the intervention, being measured values of the healthy areas and area of the darker stain. The correlation data were submitted to Person's test. The resolution by the treatments was analyzed by Student's t-test, and the difference in luminosity before and after treatments was analyzed by 2-way repeated measures Anova (p<0.05). For study 2, forty bovine enamel surfaces were subjected to demineralization. Two staining protocols were established. Twenty specimens were immersed in staining broth for 24 hours (Lab 1) or 7 days (Lab 2). Ten specimens from each group received IR application. All specimens were bleached with 15% carbamide peroxide gel for 14 days (8 hours daily). Color measurement was performed by spectrophotometry at three periods: bselien, after staining, and after bleaching. Data (CIEDE00) were analyzed by Student’s T test (p <0.05). For study 3, 4 volunteers with WSL in the maxillary teeth were selected. The patients were randomly divided into EM or RI for treating lesions. For esthetic resolution of WSL, the spot area relative to tooth area and the percentage of reduction after protocols were determined. After 12 months of follow-up, the patients received dental bleaching with 10% carbamide peroxide for 21 days. The data from study 1 show that there was no correlation between the stain areas (transilluminated or not) and the esthetic resolution (p>0.05). Regarding resolution, there was no difference between treatments (p=0.403). The Luminosity value increased after the procedures were performed (p=0.001). For study 2, no significant difference was observed in Lab 1 (p=0.560). For Lab 2, significant differences were detected (p=0.031), and whitening was more effective in the group not subjected to IR (Lab2). The results of study 3 show that both protocols reduced and/or softened the areas of the stains. After 12 months of follow-up, the EM technique showed a reduction in the stain area value. Finally, dental bleaching was effective with both protocols, with no differences between the techniques. Based on the proposed methodologies, it can be concluded that: there were no differences between the treatments regarding the removal or masking of WSL; the color of the stains when transilluminated is not related to their esthetic resolution; "in vitro", heavily stained teeth submitted to treatment with RI, the product seems to behave as a semi-permeable barrier to peroxide penetration. Finally, both techniques can be indicated to reduce or soften stained areas. The EM showed a reduction of stained areas in the evaluated period (12 months). Clinically, dental bleaching can be indicated to improve the color of teeth, regardless of the pre-established protocol.
The aim of this study was to compare enamel microabrasion (EM) and resin infiltration (RI) techniques in relation to the esthetic resolution of white spot carious lesions (WSL) and to evaluate the correlation between the luminosity of the lesions when transilluminated and the resolution of the problem (study 1); To evaluate in an "in vitro" study, the effectiveness of dental bleaching in samples of teeth previously submitted to RI (study 2); to evaluate the effectiveness of dental bleaching 12 months after the minimal intervention protocols were performed, in a case series study (study 3). For study 1, 17 patients were selected and divided into 2 groups: ME (N=8) and IR (N=9). One tooth from each patient was photographed under normal condition and the same tooth with the aid of a translume device. Then the patients were subjected to the minimal intervention techniques. After 7 days of follow-up, the same photographic protocol was performed. For esthetic resolution, the area of the tooth was delimited in relation to the area of the stain using software. To evaluate the color of the stain when evidenced, the luminosity values (L*) of the coordinates L*a*b* were evaluated before and after the intervention, being measured values of the healthy areas and area of the darker stain. The correlation data were submitted to Person's test. The resolution by the treatments was analyzed by Student's t-test, and the difference in luminosity before and after treatments was analyzed by 2-way repeated measures Anova (p<0.05). For study 2, forty bovine enamel surfaces were subjected to demineralization. Two staining protocols were established. Twenty specimens were immersed in staining broth for 24 hours (Lab 1) or 7 days (Lab 2). Ten specimens from each group received IR application. All specimens were bleached with 15% carbamide peroxide gel for 14 days (8 hours daily). Color measurement was performed by spectrophotometry at three periods: bselien, after staining, and after bleaching. Data (CIEDE00) were analyzed by Student’s T test (p <0.05). For study 3, 4 volunteers with WSL in the maxillary teeth were selected. The patients were randomly divided into EM or RI for treating lesions. For esthetic resolution of WSL, the spot area relative to tooth area and the percentage of reduction after protocols were determined. After 12 months of follow-up, the patients received dental bleaching with 10% carbamide peroxide for 21 days. The data from study 1 show that there was no correlation between the stain areas (transilluminated or not) and the esthetic resolution (p>0.05). Regarding resolution, there was no difference between treatments (p=0.403). The Luminosity value increased after the procedures were performed (p=0.001). For study 2, no significant difference was observed in Lab 1 (p=0.560). For Lab 2, significant differences were detected (p=0.031), and whitening was more effective in the group not subjected to IR (Lab2). The results of study 3 show that both protocols reduced and/or softened the areas of the stains. After 12 months of follow-up, the EM technique showed a reduction in the stain area value. Finally, dental bleaching was effective with both protocols, with no differences between the techniques. Based on the proposed methodologies, it can be concluded that: there were no differences between the treatments regarding the removal or masking of WSL; the color of the stains when transilluminated is not related to their esthetic resolution; "in vitro", heavily stained teeth submitted to treatment with RI, the product seems to behave as a semi-permeable barrier to peroxide penetration. Finally, both techniques can be indicated to reduce or soften stained areas. The EM showed a reduction of stained areas in the evaluated period (12 months). Clinically, dental bleaching can be indicated to improve the color of teeth, regardless of the pre-established protocol.
Descrição
Palavras-chave
Manchas brancas dentárias, Microabrasão do esmalte, Infiltração dentária, Clareamento dental, Estética, White spot lesions, Enamel microabrasion, Resin infiltration, Dental bleaching, Dental esthetic