Comparative Evaluation of the Multispectral Platforms Sentinel-2, CBERS-04A, and UAV for Nitrogen Detection in Maize Crops

Abstract

Multispectral images provide valuable indicators of crop nutritional status, playing a key role in strategies to reduce fertilizer use and enable supplementary applications in cases of nitrogen deficiency, thereby ensuring productivity and profitability for farmers. However, the diversity of remote sensing platforms (RSPs) makes the choice challenging, as there are few comparative studies. This study compares the remote sensing platforms Sentinel-2, CBERS-04A, and unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV), assessing their accuracy in detecting different nitrogen doses (NDs) throughout the maize crop cycle in Botucatu-SP, using 10 vegetation indices (VIs). Six NDs were tested (0, 36, 84, 132, 180, and 228 kg ha−1 of nitrogen) in nine assessments during the crop cycle. The results showed that, at the V7 stage, the RSPs were effective in detecting the NDs in eight VIs. However, at the VT stage, only the Sentinel-2 and CBERS-04A satellites demonstrated effectiveness in six VIs. Despite the high correlation among the RSPs, the ability to distinguish the NDs varied depending on the vegetation index (VI) and phenological stage. These findings highlight the importance of selecting the appropriate VI and optimal timing, regardless of the chosen platform.